1. HR Glossary
2. Interview Panel

Interview Panel

During a company's recruitment and selection process, candidates usually attend multiple interview rounds and meet numerous people who evaluate them accordingly.

Conducting, managing, and coordinating these rounds individually creates a huge mess and is time-consuming. This brings us to this article, Interview Panel, which focuses on conducting group hiring processes.

What is an Interview Panel?

An interview panel is a situation when two or more people gather and conduct an interview for the candidate. This is a situation where a group of individuals comes together to assess the candidate for the role they are applying for in an organization. This is a collective approach wherein candidates are evaluated on their skills and expertise.

The assessment committees are formed to make the hiring process more effective and to inform decision-making for improved workforce quality. One of the most common goals for arranging this assessment committee is to gather insights from different members. Each interview panel member contributes their unique point of view and expertise, which makes the hiring process very informed.

Benefits of the Interview Panel

Organizations mostly prefer the interview panel method or process for evaluating candidates. This method has many benefits, which are mentioned below for more detailed information.

1. Time Efficiency

The interviews combine the evaluation process into a single session instead of multiple interviews. This reduces the time spent on each candidate in the interview process as the panel can access the candidate simultaneously.

2. Comprehensive Assessment

When there are more than two interviewers, each panelist brings different and unique perspectives to the table, which allows for a more thorough evaluation process. This evaluation evaluates the candidate's skills, expertise, and overall fit for the role.

3. Reduced Bias

Solo interview sessions might sometimes create biases, but when conducted in a group, the chances of this are reduced. When more members are in the panel, personal preferences and biases are less likely to occur in the recruitment process and decisions.

4. Simulating Team Dynamics

These scenarios simulate real-life workplace interactions, which helps employees handle questions from multiple people at once. They also show how the candidate will act in team environments and their ability to engage the various stakeholders.

5. Enhanced Candidate Experience

When the candidate faces multiple questions from multiple interviewers, it helps them understand the company’s culture and team dynamics. This allows the candidate to assess the organization's values and whether they will fit into the structure.

6. Consistency and Structure

This type of formal communication follows a structured and uniform pattern of questions, i.e., the same questions are repeated in the same order. This consistency ensures that all the candidates are evaluated using the same criteria.

7. Improved Team Cohesion

Involving multiple team members in the panel helps strengthen work relations and team collaboration among employees. Grouping the members to hire new employees can enhance team spirit and morale, adding positivity to the workplace.

8. Higher Retention Rates

When the candidates are chosen based on their expertise and skills and with specific diverse perspectives in mind, they become a good fit for the organization. This reduces the turnover rate and helps improve job satisfaction, employee engagement, and hiring decisions.

In conclusion, the benefits of having an interview panel ensure that the hiring process is smooth and that organizational goals are achieved. Panel interviews lead to hiring better candidates and positively contributing to the workplace.

Roles and Responsibilities of Interview Panel Members

The assessment team consists of multiple members who assess the candidates collectively and make the hiring decisions. Each panel member has a unique role, and some of the roles and responsibilities of the members in the interview panel are mentioned below.

1. Hiring Supervisor

Primary Role

The hiring supervisor leads the panel and oversees the selection and hiring process. They are responsible for filling the vacancy and making the decisions accordingly.

Responsibilities

One of the supervisor's primary responsibilities is to contact HR for thorough guidance and training on the panel search process. Then, the recruitment documents and necessary criteria, like the selection process and position description, are updated. The next step includes informing all the panel members about their roles and confidential guidelines. The supervisor also ensures that each panelist participates in the screening and interview process.

2. Human Resources Representative

Primary Role

The HR representative's primary role is ensuring the hiring process complies with organizational policies and legal requirements.

Responsibilities

The responsibilities include ensuring the training sessions are conducted and addressing the interviewing techniques and legal considerations. Prepared and assisted in the questionnaire associated with the job requirement. It should be ensured that the application materials and confidential candidate information are correctly handled.

3. Subject Matter Expert (SME)

Primary Role

The subject matter expert should bring specialized knowledge for the available position and the candidate's required technical expertise.

Responsibilities

The SME is important in choosing the right candidate for the required position. They review the applicant’s materials and shortlist those with minimum qualification criteria and technical and industry-specific skills. They also offer feedback on the candidate's qualifications based on their expertise.

4. Panel/team Members

Primary Role

Other team members or peers provide valuable insights into the hiring process and the candidate's fit for the position.

Responsibility

The penal members should be ready with the candidate's application materials and understand the job requirements before the interviews. The panel interview questions should include questions on teamwork, collaboration, and interpersonal skills. Key points about the candidate’s responses should be noted for a more thorough screening process.

5. Facilitator

Primary Role

The facilitator manages the flow of the arranged interviews and ensures that they are conducted smoothly and on time.

Responsibility

The primary responsibility of a facilitator is to introduce the panel members to other members and establish rapport. The panel interview questions should be balanced, with specific questions assigned to each member. Once the interview is over, post-interview discussions should be conducted to evaluate the candidate for the hiring process.

How to Form an Effective Interview Panel

Creating a well-structured interview panel is crucial for a fair evaluation and hiring process. Here are some critical steps or points to consider to form an effective procedure.

1. Identify Key Stakeholders

Some of the key stakeholders mentioned above had specific responsibilities, such as hiring supervisors for decision-making and someone who will oversee the candidate’s work; team/peer members, the individual members in the association who will hire the new employees; HR representatives for maintaining compliance with legal laws and organizational policy; and subject matter experts for having specific knowledge of technical skills.

2. Consider Panel Size

The optimum and ideal size for the panel is 2-4 members. An excessive number of members can result in confusion and decreased efficiency, whereas too few may restrict the thoroughness of the assessment. The ideal panel size should find a middle ground, facilitating a complete evaluation without sacrificing efficiency.

Include Diverse Perspectives

This includes involving members with different backgrounds and expertise for more diverse experiences. This also consists of some junior team members along with some senior team members.

3. Clear Roles and Responsibilities

Specific roles and responsibilities should be assigned, and this should be clear enough to each panel member. Note that the questions are distributed among the members equally to avoid repetition.

5. Effective Communication

A pre-interview meeting to discuss the candidate’s qualifications, the process, and the evaluation is necessary. A post-interview meeting is also required to discuss and share feedback, such as the candidate’s strengths and weaknesses.

6. Training and Development

Specific general responsibilities of the panel members are supposed to be fulfilled during the interview process, such as active listening, interviewing skills, open-ended questions, and providing training and development if necessary. The panel members should not make decisions based on their personal opinions; rather, biases should be avoided as they influence the decisions based on them.

By following these steps or processes, any organization can improve its hiring process and, ultimately, select the right candidate for the available position who will fit into the organizational culture.

Best Practices for Conducting Panel Interviews

This is done to better align the person with the organization and culture. According to Zirtual, 34% of organizations conduct panel interviews to evaluate candidates more comprehensively, and 65% of employers involve diverse interview panels to ensure a fair and unbiased evaluation of candidates. Below are some ways to practice a smooth and efficient hiring process.

Pre-interview Preparation

1. Define the roles and responsibilities clearly and ensure that all the panel members understand the job requirements and essential qualities needed to qualify for the position.
2. Develop structured interview guidelines that include a list of questions to be asked and who will ask what type of questions.
3. Conduct training and development sessions on interview techniques, including active listening, open-ended questions, and more if needed.

During the Interview

1. It is advised that the interview be started with a warm welcome, with the panel members introduced in a welcoming environment.
2. One significant quality the panelist needs is active listening and the ability to take critical notes in a standardized form, noting every key point an interviewee mentions.
3. Ensure all the panelists are given a fair chance to question the candidate and contribute to the discussion.
4. The candidate should also be allowed to ask questions at the end of the interview, and it should not be one-sided.

Post Interview

1. Meet immediately after the process to share the initial impressions and evaluate the candidate.
2. There are many methods by which a candidate can be evaluated, such as some structured and standardized rating systems.
3. The feedback should be collected from each panel member and should be documented.
4. After this, discuss the strengths, weaknesses, and overall fit for the candidate's position.
5. The candidates should be presented with helpful feedback if they are not selected.

Following these practices can effectively help any organization conduct selection and improve the overall hiring process.

Common Challenges in Panel Interviews and how to Address Them

Interview panels can be very beneficial if implemented, but the interview panel comes with various challenges that impact both the candidate’s experience and the overall effectiveness of the process. Some of the common challenges are mentioned below.

Logistical Challenges

One of the most common challenges is managing and coordinating the work schedules of multiple panel members. Not only is this difficult, but it is also time-consuming, as it delays the process and frustrates candidates more interested in a quick selection timeline.

One solution is to plan the interviews by sharing the calendars to find expected availability times for the selection process. Virtual meetings can also be conducted but do not include travel time or location constraints.

Candidate Discomfort

Another common challenge to include here is that the candidates often feel intimidated and overwhelmed when asked multiple questions at once or even when they see various panelists together, affecting their answers and performance.

For this, the solution can be to start the interview with a warm welcome and introduce all the panel members to create a friendly atmosphere. It is advised to keep in mind the body language and tone of the panelist to create an accessible environment wherein the candidate is allowed to speak freely.

Dominance of Certain Panel Members

Sometimes, situations arise wherein the higher-ranking panelist dominates the whole conversation, leading to an unbalanced interview in which all the points are not heard.

Establishing clear objectives for forming a group that works together for the new hiring process can be the solution. All the panelists should be able to contribute to the discussion without interruption. A lead interviewer should be present at all times to ensure that everyone asks questions and follow-up questions to maintain a balance.

Extended Length of the Interviews

Panel interviews take longer than one-on-one interviews, leading to fatigue among candidates and affecting their performance.

One way to solve this problem is to prepare and maintain a strict time limit for each section. This will help the candidate focus and be efficient.

Ability to Dive Deep into Topics

When multiple panelists are present, the ability to ask follow-up questions is limited.

For this, prepare a questionnaire, which is essential as primary and requires thorough explanations. After the interview, detailed discussions can be held, and the panelists can discuss areas they want to explore further.

Conclusion

In conclusion, interview panels are a potent recruitment tool, offering many advantages that enhance the selection process. When multiple members are brought together with different backgrounds and expertise, the organization can comprehensively assess the candidates, improving the whole assessment process as the results are fair. This helps find the right candidate for the position and also helps create a positive workplace environment and culture.

FAQ

1. What are the Roles and Responsibilities of Panel Members?

Panel members should actively listen to the candidate, ask relevant questions, take notes, and participate in decision-making.

2. What Kind of Questions Should be Asked in an Interview Panel?

The questions should include behavioral, situational, and technical questions to assess the candidate's skills, experience, and cultural fit.

3. How Can We Ensure Effective Communication and Collaboration among Panel Members?

Hold pre-interview meetings to align expectations, use a shared note-taking system, and conduct post-interview debriefs.

• Previous Post Internship
• Next Post Job Analysis