1. Blogs
2. Performance Improvement Plan (PIP): Strategies to Boost Employee Performance

Performance Improvement Plan (PIP): Strategies to Boost Employee Performance

• Get a summary in:

Hiring the right talent requires significant time, effort, and money for most organizations; despite these investments, many employees are unable to deliver the desired results or meet the expectations of their role. Research indicates that a majority of workers are not fully engaged, thereby increasing hiring and training costs. Disengagement also impacts productivity and business goals and adds pressure on the rest of the team.

To overcome this challenge, Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs) are the most effective and structured solution for helping many employees. These plans create clarity, accountability, and measurable growth for employees, improving motivation and retention.

What is a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)?

The purpose of a Performance Improvement Plan is a formal document created by an employer to identify specific performance issues of an employee. This formal document helps address specific performance deficiencies and meet expectations. It allows employees to set measurable performance goals and clarify the support the organization will provide. It also includes a defined timeline and a review process to assess progress before further action is taken.

It is a formal document that functions as a roadmap for the employee and documentation for the employer.

Where are Pips Used?

Many departments use PIPs to improve employee performance. Here are a few instances where different departments use PIPs for different reasons:

• In sales, PIPs help improve follow-ups and conversions.
• In customer service, PIPs help reduce delays and improve the quality of support.
• In operations and logistics, PIPs help employees follow the process, reduce mistakes, and finish tasks on time.
• In administrative, Human Resources (HR), and IT roles, they clarify accountability for project delivery, documentation, and deadlines.

PIPs provide every employee with a fair opportunity to understand the areas that require improvement and the support available to achieve better performance.

Advantages of Having a Performance Improvement Plan

A well-implemented PIP gives employees a chance to succeed rather than facing immediate consequences. Here are a few advantages for both the employer and employees:

1) Improved Productivity

PIPs help identify skill or workflow gaps early and give employees the guidance they need to improve. With the desired support and advice, not only does the employee perform better, but overall employee team productivity is enhanced.

2) Legal Protection

Transparency and documentation of PIPs reduce the risk of legal conflicts for both employees and the organization. Since everyone understands the goals, the time allowed for improvement, and the support the employee will receive, there are fewer misunderstandings.

3) Better Communication

PIPs are effective in improving relationships between managers and employees, as they provide regular opportunities to discuss progress, clarify concerns, and resolve issues before they escalate.

4) Enhanced Employee Engagement

The support, tools, and resources that PIPs offer employees make them feel more valued and engaged. When support replaces criticism, this builds confidence and encourages personal accountability. Higher engagement boosts performance and retention, which is crucial for organizational success.

5) Improved Retention

Helping a struggling employee succeed is more cost-effective than replacing them. A successful PIP can turn a potential exit into a long-term asset for the business. Higher Employee retention reduces the hiring and training costs for organizations while boosting productivity.

6) Focused Skill Development

PIPs highlight specific training needs, whether technical or behavioral. Employees gain new strengths that continue to benefit performance beyond the plan.

Common Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Even though PIPs can be highly effective, they require thoughtful execution to avoid common challenges.

1) Impact on Morale and Trust

A PIP can sometimes lower confidence and create tension between the employee and their manager if it is seen as punishment. Employees may worry about job security, feel singled out, or become less engaged.

Managers should clearly explain the plan’s purpose, show confidence in the employee’s ability to improve, and communicate regularly to overcome this barrier. When the intent is transparent and focused on growth, it builds trust and makes the employee more willing to participate wholeheartedly in the process.

2) Time and Resources

Implementing PIPs requires significant time, effort, and resources. Managers need to allocate time to coaching, feedback, and progress tracking. However, this upfront effort is far more cost-effective than losing a trained employee and hiring a replacement, making the investment worthwhile in the long run.

3) Limited Effectiveness

A PIP may not be effective if the root causes of poor performance are not addressed or if the employee lacks the necessary skills or resources to improve. Starting with a precise diagnosis and providing the proper support ensures employees have what they need to improve.

PIP Checklist: What to Include

A successful PIP must be specific, structured, and supportive. These elements make expectations clear and provide employees with a genuine opportunity to improve.

1) Clear Performance Gaps

The plan should identify performance gaps in detail and provide recent evidence through feedback or actual work examples.

2) Measurable and Role-Based Goals

Every improvement goal should directly connect to the employee’s role and be measurable, such as response times, sales numbers, or error reduction. Define the evaluation criteria and the indicators of success to give the employee a clear direction for improvement.

3) Defined Timeline

Depending on the nature of the job role, most PIPs run for 30–90 days. The timeline should include regular progress checks, such as after the first week to set direction, and again around the fourth and eighth weeks to review improvements. The duration needs to be fair, giving enough time for real progress while still maintaining urgency.

4) Support and Resources

The PIP should specify the support and resources to be provided, such as training, access to better tools, mentoring, or closer guidance from the manager. It must also clarify who the employee can approach for help and how often. Organizations must offer consistent support throughout the process to demonstrate that the employee is valued.

5) Regular Check-Ins and Documentation

Regular check-ins or feedback can give both the manager and employee a shared view of the PIP’s progress and allow issues to be resolved before they escalate. Keeping notes from these discussions prevents confusion later, while recognizing even minor improvements motivates employees.

Avoid these PIP Mistakes

Even a well-designed PIP can fail if execution is unclear, rushed, or unfair.

1) Unclear or Unmeasurable Expectations

Vague goals like “improve attitude” or “be more proactive” make the process confusing and subjective. Instead, state exactly what needs to be changed, such as accuracy issues, missed deadlines, or communication lapses. Employees must understand how improvement will be judged so they can focus on the actions.

2) No Ongoing Feedback

Handing over a PIP and waiting until the final review increases stress and reduces the chance of success. Regular check-ins help prevent minor issues from becoming larger performance setbacks and support continuous progress.

3) Unrealistic Deadlines

Tight deadlines can create the impression that improvement is unattainable. The time given should push the employee to do better while still being realistic for the work they handle every day.

4) Lack of Support or Guidance

A PIP is meant to help employees succeed, not push them out the door. If resources and guidance are lacking, even competent employees may struggle to improve, creating an unfair process.

5) Using PIP as a Pre-Dismissal Formality

Treating a PIP as a step before termination breaks trust and lowers morale. Employees can sense when the outcome is already decided, and it also increases the risk of disputes or legal action.

5 Steps for Creating a Successful Performance Improvement Plan

Employee success should be the primary goal of any performance improvement initiative. Once a PIP is confirmed as the right approach, following these five steps helps ensure real change.

Step 1 – Identify the Specific Areas of Underperformance

Start by reviewing the employee’s work over the last 3 to 6 months, including KPIs, quality concerns, and feedback from supervisors or colleagues. Managers should also ask employees about the roadblocks they’re facing, to uncover issues such as unclear expectations or an imbalance in workload that need to be addressed.

Step 2 – Set Clear and Measurable Goals

The improvement expectations must be specific, measurable, and related to the role. For example, managers can ask employees to improve report accuracy or to respond to client queries within the expected timeframe. When performance metrics are clear, the employee knows exactly what success looks like and how progress will be assessed.

Step 3 – Identify Resources and Support Needed

Training programs, access to better tools or systems, mentorship, or closer guidance from the manager are essential for improvement.

Step 4 – Establish a Timeline and Regular Check-Ins

Most PIPs run 30 to 120 days, depending on the role. Setting milestone checkpoints, for example, at Week 1, Week 4, and Week 8, allows managers to track progress early and often. These check-ins help both parties discuss challenges before they slow down improvement and ensure everyone stays aligned.

Step 5 – Review Progress and Adjust as Needed

As the employee works through the plan, progress should be reviewed against the agreed goals. If improvement is visible but slower than expected, timelines or support can be adjusted. The aim is to help the employee succeed in their role, and flexibility and open communication remain essential until the plan concludes.

Having the PIP Conversation

The success of a PIP often depends on how the first discussion is handled. Implementing such procedures requires preparation to set the right tone. Here’s what managers need to do:

• Before the meeting, managers should gather relevant data, review past feedback, and identify the support they will provide to keep the conversation factual and focused on improvement.
• During the meeting, it is essential to clearly communicate that the PIP is not a punishment; it exists to help the employee succeed in the role. Expressing belief in the employee’s ability to meet expectations builds confidence and motivation.
• The PIP conversation should not be one-sided; it should also invite the employee to share the challenges they are experiencing and the support that may help them improve. When they feel involved in shaping the plan, they take greater ownership of the outcome.
• Maintaining respect and transparency throughout the discussion creates psychological safety for the employee. This makes it easier for the employee to ask questions, clarify doubts, and commit to the process with a positive mindset.

Real-World Examples of Pips That Worked

PIPs have worked in many scenarios, driving meaningful performance changes with clear expectations, accountability, and genuine support.

Case 1

A representative missed several opportunities due to the inability to follow up with leads promptly. The PIP plan for this sales employee charted out CRM training and weekly coaching sessions, with a 60-day timeline and weekly tracking. As a result, the employee achieved faster response times and improved sales conversion rates. In fact, the employee was promoted for excellent sales performance.

Case 2

An operations coordinator struggled to prioritize tasks, leading to frequent delays in deliverables. The PIP helped streamline workflows and introduced daily check-ins for the first two weeks. Over 45 days with a midpoint review, accuracy improved, and the employee started meeting deadlines consistently.

Did you know McKinsey reports that 60% of respondents who rate their performance-management systems as effective say their companies have outperformed peers in the past three years. This data shows that effective performance-management systems deliver almost three times better improvement results than ineffective ones, highlighting the value of a strong and thoughtfully executed PIP process.

Conclusion

A Performance Improvement Plan, when implemented effectively, benefits both the employee and the organization. When goals are transparent, progress is regularly reviewed, and communication remains open, employees feel guided rather than judged.

The result is stronger performance, better retention, and a workplace where people are given a fair chance to succeed. To put these principles into practice, explore factoHR’s Performance Management tool that makes performance tracking and development easier for every team.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a PIP Lead to Termination?

Not necessarily. A PIP is meant to help employees succeed by offering clear goals and support. If improvements occur within the set timeline, the plan is closed successfully. Termination is considered only when there is no progress despite guidance.

Should I Accept a PIP or Resign?

Accepting a PIP is usually the better first step. It gives a fair chance to improve and show commitment. Resignation should only be considered if the role no longer aligns with career goals or if expectations cannot realistically be met.

Should I Quit if I Get a PIP?

There is no need to quit immediately. A PIP offers an opportunity to address challenges and prove capability. Many employees complete PIPs successfully and continue to grow in their organization.

Is a PIP a Final Warning?

In many companies, it is considered a serious step, but not always a final one. It serves as a structured improvement process before disciplinary measures are taken. When approached with effort and support, it can lead to positive outcomes.

• Previous Post Performance Appraisals and Ways to Better The Process – FactoHR
• Next Post Performance Management System (PMS) – A Complete Guide