Best Interview Feedback With Examples & Templates

Table of Contents

Interview feedback offers a dual-advantage approach. It allows candidates to gain insights into their strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement while helping organizations enhance their hiring processes and brand reputation.

This depends on interview experience and a candidate’s feedback from any company’s HR department. This is why it becomes crucial to have a sound interview feedback mechanism that enhances the overall experience for any candidate.

This article blends in an interview feedback mechanism for employers and candidates to ensure a win-win for both parties. It focuses on different interview best practices, proper feedback, and templates for human resource managers. Let’s first understand interview feedback!

What is Interview Feedback?

Interview feedback is a formal assessment that job applicants receive after an interview. It provides insights into their performance, highlighting strengths and areas for development. Feedback can be positive, constructive, or negative depending on how well the candidate meets the job requirements.

Positive feedback acknowledges the applicant’s qualifications, skills, and standout qualities. For example, it might mention strong technical expertise or excellent communication skills. Constructive criticism offers practical advice to help candidates improve their abilities or gain more experience. Negative feedback addresses shortcomings, such as missing qualifications, but it’s delivered respectfully to avoid discouraging applicants.

Positive feedback is essential because it can make or break a candidate’s relationship with an organization. A LinkedIn report indicates that 52% of candidates receiving feedback are likelier to continue their relationship with the interviewing organization.

Best Practices For Requesting Interview Feedback

An integral component of the job application process is requesting interview comments. It might give an insightful analysis of your performance and guide you toward betterment for the subsequent interviews. These are the ideal guidelines for getting comments on an interview:

Time is of the essence; get comments shortly following the interview, preferably within one week. This will enable the interviewers to give more accurate comments and to recall your engagement freshly.
Always write professionally, politely, and courteously. Start with a quick thank-you note stating that you value the chance to interview.
Ask specific questions that will direct the interviewer in their answer when you seek comments. You might, for instance, probe specific areas such as your credentials, approach to interviews, or answers to particular queries.
Maintaining respect for the interviewer’s time, make your request brief. Enough is said in a few lines thanking them and explicitly indicating your need for comments.
Be receptive to constructive criticism; approach comments with an open mind. Though it is not a personal attack, constructive criticism is meant to help you grow.
Tell them straight up whether you still find the job or company appealing. This will help keep the door open for prospects.
Remember that several elements might influence recruiting decisions, so you should not take it personally. Use the comments as a teaching tool rather than a yardstick of your value.
If you are still waiting for a reply within a week or so, it is reasonable to write a polite follow-up. Still, avoid becoming demanding or aggressive.
Show thanks to the interviewer for investing the time to answer the comments you get. Should new prospects develop, this helps to preserve a good relationship.
Think through and respond to comments carefully. Reflect on what was said and evaluate how you can improve in the subsequent interviews.

Types of Interview Feedback

Positive Feedback

Positive comments highlight the candidate’s qualifications, abilities, and any particularly noteworthy strengths from the interview. However, more relevant technical knowledge or excellent communication abilities might be needed.

Constructive Feedback

Conversely, constructive criticism provides practical guidance, advising candidates to enhance their talents or expand their experiences. Negative comments center on shortcomings, such as the absence of required credentials, but they also show respect and sensitivity to help avoid despair.

Giving candidates interview comments helps them and the company. It displays professionalism and openness, strengthening the company’s reputation.

Forms of Interview Response

Positive Response

This kind of feedback emphasizes giving insights, especially to the applicant, to enable them to evaluate their performance and guide future results.

Follow-up Response

Candidates are invited to consider their performance following an interview. This entails closely reading their answers, body language, and general interview impressions.

Evaluation Response

Self-evaluation enables applicants to identify their areas of strength and development need.

Example of Technical Interview Feedback

To provide candidates with specific insights into their technical performance during the interview, highlighting strengths and areas for improvement.

Example 1: Positive Feedback

Subject: Comments on Your Technical [Job Title] Interview at [Company Name]

From [Candidate’s Name],

We appreciate you considering the [Job Title] post and interviewing. We value your interest in and effort in joining [Company Name].

Strengths

You showed outstanding problem-solving skills, particularly in algorithm design, where you effectively optimized the solution.
Technical Knowledge: Your grasp of [specific technology or idea] was outstanding and fit our project needs.
Your code was easily understandable and maintainable since it was neat, well-documented, and followed top standards.

Areas Needing Work

Time Management: Giving additional time to the part of system design can help clarify your answer.
Handling Edge Cases: Although your answers were strong in real-world applications, paying more attention to edge circumstances helps prevent possible problems.

We were generally pleased with your technical ability, so we advise you to keep developing it. We will consider your profile for prospects who fit your experience.

I appreciate your interest in [Company Name]. We hope your future activities and job hunt go well.

Good regards,

[Your entire name]

[Your job title]

[ Company Name ]

[Contacts Information]

Example 2: Constructive Feedback

Subject: Feedback on Your Technical Interview for [Job Title] at [Company Name]

Dear [Candidate’s Name],

Thank you for interviewing for the [Job Title] position at [Company Name]. We appreciate the time you invested in the process.

Strengths

Analytical Thinking: Your approach to breaking down complex problems was commendable and showcased solid analytical skills.
Technical Enthusiasm: Your passion for [specific technology or field] was evident and aligns with our team’s interests.

Areas for Improvement

Coding Efficiency: Optimizing your solution for better time complexity would enhance performance in the coding exercise, especially for large datasets.
Framework Familiarity: Gaining more hands-on experience with [specific framework or tool] would strengthen your candidacy for roles requiring these skills.
Communication: While your technical answers were solid, articulating your thought process more clearly can improve collaboration and understanding within a team setting.

We encourage you to continue developing these areas and consider applying for future positions that match your evolving skill set. Your dedication to learning is evident, and we believe you have great potential.

Thank you again for considering [Company Name]—best of luck in your career pursuits.

Sincerely,

[Your Full Name]

[Your Job Title]

[Company Name]

[Contact Information]

Interview Feedback Template

Here are some templates that you can use to encourage candidates to keep improving their abilities and strengthen your profile as a company that welcomes open communication.

Example 1 – Template for Interviewers Providing Feedback to Candidates

Subject: Comments on [Candidate’s Name] Interviews The [Position Title]

Dear [Candidate’s Name],

We appreciate you investing time to interview for the [Position Title] post on [Date]. We value your enthusiasm for [Company Name] and would like to provide you with some comments on your interview.

Strengths:

[Quickly note a strength, such as strong technical skills, shown during the interview.]

[ Another advantage is good articulation of expertise and effective communication.]

Domains of Enhancement:

[Area needs work, e.g., offering more specific instances when discussing project difficulties.]

[ Another area, e.g., working on keeping eye contact, can improve your presence during interviews.]

All-around impression: Although we thought you would be a strong applicant for the job, we opted to proceed with another individual who more precisely fit our present requirements. We think you have tremendous potential; hence, we advise you to apply for the following positions.

Once more, we appreciate your attention; we hope your job hunt goes well.

Best wishes.

[YourName]

[Your Location]

[Company name]

Example 2 – Template for Candidates Providing Feedback on the Interview Process

Subject: Opinions on [Position Title] Interview Process

Hi [Hiring Manager’s Name],

With any luck, this communication will reach you intact. I want to comment on my most recent [Position Title] interview on [Date].

Overall Experience:

[Positive comment on the experience, e.g., the interview setting was professional and friendly.]

What Went Good?

[Highlight anything you valued, say, The interview panel offered perceptive questions and was well-prepared.]

Areas for Development:

[ constructive comments, e.g., Candidates would benefit from better-advanced knowledge of the interview style.]

Further Notes: I value your time committed to the process and the chance to interview for the post. I appreciate you considering my application; your comments will be much awaited.

Excellent regards,

{Your Name}

[Your Contact Details]

Interview Feedback Comments From Recruiters

Recruiters are often in charge of the hiring process and offer a more general understanding. This can involve the candidate’s overall employability depending on industry expertise, communication during the recruiting process, and how well they suit the position. Employer-centric feedback enables companies to enhance their employment policies and guide their decisions.

Employers may ask candidates for comments on how they handled the interview process. Candidates can provide opinions on the interview’s fairness, clarity, and organization, enabling companies to improve the procedure for the following candidates.

Comment on candidates’ performance to the job criteria. This entails evaluating their qualifications, aptitudes for the position, and abilities. This input enables companies to spot areas where candidates require development and high talent.

How to Provide Interview Feedback

Hiring managers and interviewers have an outstanding obligation to provide feedback. It can improve the hiring process and allow candidates to grasp their performance and grow for the next chance. These are the excellent guidelines for offering interview comments:

1. Be Timely

Comment as soon as you can after the interview. This guarantees that candidates can move fast on the comments and that details are still fresh in their minds.

2. Be Exact and Helpful

Pay close attention to particular facets of the applicant’s performance. Talk about specific strengths or areas of development rather than generalizations. Say, for instance, “Your answers could have been more structured” instead of “You didn’t do well.”

3. Manage Positive and Negative Comments

Measurefully emphasize the candidate’s areas of strength and weakness. This will help the applicant and facilitate their acceptance of helpful criticism.

4. Use the Right Examples

When discussing shortcomings or strengths, include particular interview responses or actions. This clarifies for the candidates what they need to work on or what they performed well.

5. Keep a Professional Tone

Speak in your language respectfully and professionally. Comments should be meant to assist the candidate rather than discourage them. Avoid statements that are too personal or forceful.

6. Promote Questions

After offering comments, let the applicant probe more. This clarifies any issues they might not grasp and shows you value for their growth.

7. Centre on Fit and Skills

Discuss how their qualifications fit the job and corporate culture. Comments should be relevant to the job criteria and assist the applicant in seeing where they could or could not fit in.

8. Suggest Resources or Advice

Advise candidates on areas they could want to develop. This could involve suggesting specific books, courses, or strategies to improve their abilities.

9. Follow-up

Offer to keep in touch or offer future direction if suitable. This helps build a good rapport and motivates the applicant to seek guidance.

Following these best practices will assist you in presenting explicit, valuable interview comments that inspire candidates.

Candidate Feedback on the Interview Process

Organizations trying to improve their hiring policies and the whole candidate experience depend on applicant comments on the interview process. Such comments usually center on several aspects of the interview process, giving companies information on what goes right and what may be done better.

Key areas often discussed in candidate comments are broken out here together with justifications:

Preparation and Transmission

Candidates value transparent communication about the interview process, including logistics, format, and expectations. Feedback could indicate whether they received sufficient pre-interview information—the agenda or the subjects to cover.

Candidates often ask whether they were given timely information on changes, the general course of decisions, and interview schedules. Good experience and professionalism reflect quick communication.

Environment for Interview

Candidates may remark, whether in person or virtually, how kind and comfortable the interview setting was. A laid-back environment can help a candidate perform better and view the organization favorably.

Comments on interviewers’ attitudes, behavior, and readiness abound. Candidates’ image of the corporate culture is shaped in part by the interviewers’ respect, involvement, and knowledge.

Structural Interview Questions

Candidates typically respond by determining whether the questions are pertinent to the job title. Constructive comments can also cover whether the questions accurately assess the person’s qualifications, experience, and suitability for the business.

The response could include comments on the clarity of the questions and whether they believed the interview process was fair and reasonably designed to evaluate all candidates based on the same criteria.

Pace and Duration

Candidates may express tension about the interview being shorter or, in this regard, feedback can enable companies to balance acquiring enough information, causing candidates to feel overburdened or tired.

Candidates may remark on the interview’s pace, indicating whether the interviewers gave sufficient time for responses. Rather than a rapid-fire Q&A session, a well-paced interview can encourage a fruitful debate.

Reactions and Follow-Up

Candidates may ask whether they got comments from the interviewees and whether they were told about upcoming process phases. Positive comments are appreciated and show a company’s dedication to candidate development.

Comments might relate to candidates’ reaction times—their response to decisions announced following an interview. Response delays might cause annoyance and unfavorable opinions of the hiring company.

How to Ask for Interview Feedback

By helping you discover your strengths and development areas, asking about interview comments is a proactive action to support your future job search activities. This is a complete guide on requesting feedback during an interview:

Time is everything, so seeking comments following a rejection is advisable, even if the interview process ends without a definite following action. Get in touch a few days to a week following the choice to make sure the interviewer remembers your conversation.
Choose the correct email channel to share the feedback. This is usually the most official and often utilized approach to requesting comments. It lets the interviewer respond whenever it is most convenient. If you already know each other, sending a nice LinkedIn message could also be appropriate.
Create a brief, professional message ensuring your request is clear, polite, and straightforward.
When customizing your request reference details, specify the position, interview date, or other pertinent information to show that you are attentive. Show a desire for development and education instead of only criticism.
Show Consideration and Empathy-Acknowledge that providing comments requires effort and that the interviewer might be busy. Send short messages to demonstrate regard for their time. Instead, keep your request brief.

Value of Candidate Interview Comments

Asking for candidate feedback on the interview process is also crucial. It helps the human resources department focus on areas for improvement throughout the process. Getting particular candidate feedback helps recognize pain points and flaws in an interview process.

This helps companies improve processes and create a more open hiring approach. Also, giving applicants constructive criticism requires proper planning and a creative approach that does not impact the brand value.

Conclusion

Giving and receiving comments during interviews is a great way to improve the hiring process for companies and candidates. Best practices and templates will help hiring managers and candidates establish positive conversations. This promotes development and openness and improves candidates’ learning.

Companies can use the feedback mechanism to create a more prosperous and efficient hiring process that benefits all those engaged. However, analyzing the candidate profile and identifying strengths and weaknesses to share feedback need effective software. This is where factoHR can help. Schedule a free demo today to learn more about our HR solutions.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Can HR Departments Ensure That Interview Feedback Is Fair and Unbiased?

To ensure fair and unbiased feedback, HR departments should establish clear evaluation criteria, train interviewers to avoid biases, conduct regular reviews of feedback practices, and gather feedback from candidates to identify potential issues.

What Is Positive Interview Feedback?

When giving positive interview feedback, emphasize the candidate’s strengths, such as their technical skills, communication abilities, and project management expertise. Providing specific examples can make the feedback more impactful.

How Can HR Departments Ensure That Interview Feedback Is Delivered Effectively and Respectfully?

HR departments should:

Be timely: Provide feedback promptly after the interview.
Be specific: Focus on concrete examples and areas for improvement.
Be constructive: Avoid overly negative or discouraging language.
Be professional: Maintain a respectful and courteous tone.
Offer follow-up: Provide additional support or resources if needed.

How do you write a follow-up email after the interview?

Subject line: Thank you for the [Job Title] interview at [Company Name]

Hi [Interviewer’s Name],

I want to thank you for the opportunity to interview for the [Job Title] position at [Company Name]. It was great to meet you and learn more about the company.

I am excited about the chance to contribute to your organization and look forward to the next steps in the hiring process. Please let me know if you need anything else from me.

Thank you once again for your time and consideration. I hope to hear from you soon..

Sincerely,

Antonio Rodrigues

How Can HR Departments Use Interview Feedback to Improve Their Hiring Processes?

HR departments can use interview feedback to identify areas for improvement, assess hiring criteria, measure hire quality, train interviewers, and enhance candidate experience.

What Are Some Common Mistakes That HR Departments Make When Providing Interview Feedback?

Common mistakes in providing interview feedback include vague feedback, focusing solely on negatives, neglecting follow-up, and disregarding candidate preferences.

Grow your business with factoHR today

Focus on the significant decision-making tasks, transfer all your common repetitive HR tasks to factoHR and see the things falling into their place.

Request Free Trial