HR Benchmarking: Definition, types and meaning
Table of Contents
Every organisation should understand where it is on the business market concerning the opposition. Furthermore, it should survey how its various teams and departments contrast with each other. Along these lines, do you stand behind all of the others regarding the worker turnover rate? Do you have any innovative teams that have presented new methods your company should introduce in the entire organisation? As noted in an article by the Harvard Business School, identifying milestones will give you something to compare your performance with the best. The next article is dedicated more to benchmarking, so see it here!
What is HR Benchmarking ?
HR Benchmarking is a process that involves the comparison of an organisation with other best-performing organisations. Here, we will track down and put in place the most efficient practices across the business. It can be used to test everything from macro levels of organisational effectiveness to micro levels of the daily activities like employee recruitment and future training. It poses a useful opportunity for companies that are willing to improve their productivity.
Meaning and Definition of HR Benchmarking
Firstly let’s understand the benchmark meaning. HR benchmarking is an effective method for assessing organisational performance by comparing various indicators and features to internal or external benchmarks. The aim is to understand how an organisation compares itself with other market leaders and competitors. Along with this, it will check areas for improvement to reach that stage.
To set benchmarks in HR, organisations must choose relevant indicators to compare. These indicators are like employee turnover rate, timely recruiting, and other characteristics indicating employee engagement. These indicators should be selected based on their relevance with the organisational goals and the availability of market data. Organisations should also keep a check on their, HR policies and organisational practices. This can help the organisations to get a clear idea of their overall performance.
Setting benchmarks can be effective in some situations, but it also has its limitations. Setting benchmarks may not always be possible, particularly for some types of businesses. But instead ensuring that data is genuinely comparable might be difficult due to the variations in organisational size, industrial areas, or geographical regions.
Furthermore, for significant change to happen in an organisation, setting benchmarks requires competent data analysis and interpretation. Organisations have to make sure that their daily operations are carried out with dedication to continuous improvement, and with a focus on executing effective ideas.
Types of HR Benchmarking
There are various types of benchmarks in HR that organisations can use to obtain insights and find areas for improvement, each tailored to a specific organisational requirement and goal. Before delving into four primary setting benchmark categories, it's crucial to remember that organisations can use numerous types depending on their own needs and aims. The type that works best for a firm is greatly influenced by its priorities, accessible data, and desired results.
The following are the types of HR benchmarking
Internal Benchmarking
Internal benchmarking entails comparing data from various teams, departments, or groups inside the same organisation. It enables organisations to discover relative strengths and weaknesses while fostering knowledge exchange and collaboration across departments.
External Benchmarking
External benchmarking is the process of comparing HR measurements and procedures to those of other organisations, typically within the same industry or sector. This form of setting benchmarks allows businesses to gain knowledge about industry norms, optimal procedures, and developing trends. By comparing oneself to competitors, businesses might find performance gaps and new growth prospects.
External benchmark setting is further separated into two categories: competitive benchmarking and functional benchmarking. Competitive benchmarking, as the name suggests, compares HR measurements and procedures to those of direct competitors. Functional benchmarking, on the other hand, is concerned with identifying how and why competing organisations succeed in specific areas.
Strategic Benchmarking
Strategic benchmarking compares an organisation's overall human resources strategy to those of other industry leaders, in addition to HR measurements and practices. It investigates high-level issues such as the alignment of HR strategy with organisational goals, the efficacy of talent management processes, and HR's ability to react to changing business requirements. This type of benchmark reveals novel HR practices that can propel long-term organisational performance.
Process Benchmarking
Process benchmarking concentrates on specific HR procedures or activities, such as training and development programmes or employee engagement initiatives. It entails comparing process efficiency, performance, and outcomes to other organisations to identify areas for improvement and innovation.
Process of Benchmarking in HR
To understand the benchmarking process, you can consider the following steps
Choose a Specific Business Field to Focus Your Benchmarking Operations
While you can evaluate various aspects of HR, it's ideal to focus on one. For example, you can assess anything from your workforce composition and organisational structure to your HR department's budget, but attempting to do so everything at once would make it difficult to emerge from the standard process with a clear view of what to improve and how.
Gather Internal Information and Data
As noted in the preceding phase, you should specify the metrics you will utilise as points of reference in your setting benchmarks in the HR process. If you want to benchmark regularly as part of your business performance improvement strategy. HR analytics solutions not only provide you with workforce data and insights, but they also assist you in designing and implementing HR initiatives that will improve your company's future.
Collect External or Previous Data to Compare
Now comes one of the most difficult aspects of the process: gathering external benchmarking data—or internal data from years ago. Make sure you're looking at companies in the same industry, the same size, and, if possible, in the same geographical area. Also, note that obtaining a competitor's data is not an easy operation; most workforce data is considered confidential, so if you take this path, you have few options.
Analyse the Differences Between Your Measurements and the Comparison Data
Once you've gathered all of the necessary data for setting benchmarks in HR (both internal and external or historical information), it's time to compare measures. To achieve this, create a spreadsheet or report that compares the two sets of measurements, then highlight where the data aligns and where there are substantial differences.
Develop a Plan for Growth Based on Your Analysis
Your examination of the setting benchmarks data should reveal which aspects of your people strategy may be improved. The next step is to put pen to paper and brainstorm how you can accomplish this. The plan you build should directly address the factors you feel are causing performance differences.
Assess the Effectiveness of Your Plan
Of course, any time you initiate an improvement strategy, you have to track the results to precisely determine if it was effective or not. Fortunately, you are already aware of which metrics to focus on, as they were the ones that sparked your development strategy.
What Are the Metrics of HR Benchmarking?
When setting benchmarks in HR, focus on meaningful metrics. While exact KPIs may differ depending on business goals, some are universally significant.
Employee Absence Rate
Every organisation strives to provide the finest environment for their employees to complete their responsibilities while feeling fulfilled. Your organisation should strive for work-life balance by granting its employees the right to take vacation time.
That being said, the absence rate is an important metric for determining whether your staff adhere to a standard across organisations. For effective workforce management you can design a proper leave policy. Measuring absenteeism can help you determine your employees' returns on investment and productivity.
Cost of Recruitment
This measure calculates the entire hiring costs, including agency fees, travel expenses, relocation charges, and employee referral bonuses. Optimising these costs to the benchmark of other organisations can reduce the organisation's overall expenses while increasing profit.
Maintaining a long-term working relationship with a staffing agency will keep all of these costs under control since they will use best practices to source the best personnel on your behalf at a cheaper cost than if you were to recruit and source individuals internally.
Full-time Equivalent
Full-time equivalent is about the total working hours of an employee completed by both full-time and part-time employees in an organisation. This aspect considers the working hours of all the employees in an organisation. This also helps to evaluate the effort and productivity of all teams in the organisation. Evaluating the working hours into FTEs, it provides a primary indicator for evaluating the efficiency of all the employees in the organisation (full-time, part-time, and contractual).
FTE provides a brief highlight into employee performance, allowing you to analyse their eligibility for rewards and incentives. Furthermore, if your employee asks for a salary increase, you must evaluate their performance and determine whether or not they are entitled to the raise. As a result, your organisation's retention rates will rise while its turnover rate falls.
Vacancy Time to Fill
If an organisation has open positions, it must fill them as soon as possible with the most skilled and trained employees. If it takes a long time to fill the job position, then it will have an impact on workflow. It may also affect a company's performance and achievement of its objectives.
This benchmark evaluates an organisation's recruiters' ability to find and hire suitable candidates. To calculate recruiting expenses, you must first determine the average time it takes to fill openings.
Where Can Benchmarking Be Applied in an Organisation?
Performance Evaluation
At the most basic level, HR benchmarks assist organisations in completely evaluating the effectiveness of their HR department. Benchmarking helps organisations to identify the performance gaps, recognise organisation's strengths, and set achievable goals for development. Setting benchmarks helps organisations to stay updated with new developments and best practices.
Make Wise Decisions
We get strategic HR benchmarks which are used to overview the statistical data for the decision-making process of managers. Institutes can make a right selection about resource division, HR functions, and general business mode when they utilise a data benchmark, which in turn they can promulgate accurate decisions.
Continuous Growth
By establishing HR benchmarks, organisations become centerstages for the careers of their people. Churning out quality and desirable candidates becomes the prime responsibility of the organisations. The purpose of these companies will stimulate their activities to move ahead with better standards. To what extent this will occur depends on the conduct of the management that must routinely assess their organisational performance. It links the services or products that are offered by such businesses with the available resources which can be used and brings in new ways and application of these ideas to make the HR function strong.
Competitive Advantage
Having HR benchmarks in your organisation makes it easier to move ahead of others in the practice of human resource management. Fixedness of benchmarks can exist, for example, current trends in the industry. This is likely to exist because it gives the companies the choice to revisit their HR (human resource) practices. This is to fill the spaces where the demands may keep on changing and as a way of leading the market competition. Moreover, such an imagination of what other organisations are doing is also very helpful in identifying where one's own organisation is failing and inspiring the formation of new activities to cope with the particular issue.
Organisational Accountability and Transparency
Establishing organisational accountability and transparency could potentially come through creating benchmarks. This is because of the benefits it gives since it’s a reference point for organisations when they benchmark and evaluate themselves. Also, they could convey those kinds of feedback through the employees. Then, the business closely tracks its progress through varied indicators such as how many sub-targets it has reached, and the information is shared with its team members. Hence, the efforts of citizens to sort out fact-checking and rise above rumours can significantly contribute to the creation of trust and credibility.
What can be Benchmarked by an Organisation?
As long as you have the data, you may benchmark almost any area of your organisation's human resources. Here are several sorts of benchmarks you can consider
Organisational Structure
Organisational design and structure play an important role in putting corporate strategy into effect. An organisation can compare its internal structure to see whether it is best suited to the goals it seeks to achieve. Organisations can be structured in a variety of ways, including by function or product, as well as centralised versus decentralised.
Employee Salaries
Setting benchmarks in employee salaries allows organisations to compare their salaries with other organisations. Along with it, it also benefits specific industries, organisations, and locations. It is an important tool to determine whether your organisation is underpaying or overpaying staff. The payroll reconciliation can also be determined by this. So, there are reports generated expressly for each sector and area to provide pertinent data.
HR Expenses
HR expenditures include a variety of indicators. This could include the cost of operating the HR department or covering HR budget criteria such as cost per recruit. As with other measures, it is critical to ensure that the data is consistent and comparable among organisations with similar features.
Career Advancement Across the Employee Life Cycle
Another crucial indicator to compare is professional advancement. This can be measured in a variety of ways, including the number of lateral or vertical movements, the frequency of talent and leadership development programmes, and the opportunities available to all employees. Consider promotion rate as a known measure to compare. It tracks how often people are promoted within the organisation.
Health and Productivity
Employee wellness programmes have expanded in importance as a result of remote work, COVID-19, and increased mental health awareness. This is necessary for any organisation to determine whether their health and wellness programmes compare to others and have an influence on productivity.
Employee Work Schedule and Working Environment
This parameter is supposed to depict how you are bearing with the staff in the organisation. On the other hand, the factor still helps as it provides insight regarding the employees' working environment. This is a better solution so as to scrutinise whether an organisation is achieving its goals by having working hours and an environment that fits well with its business or not. It allows companies with defined shifts to be able to predict the resources they need. This is across counters and customer service areas. Apart from this, it acts as a benchmark mandating organisations having special responsibilities to comply with the stated requirements. Through this, a suitable working environment is achieved not only for the staff but also for everybody in the company.
Engagement and Retention
Employee engagement and retention are two of the most important performance indicators for any organisation. It is a direct measurement of people's practices and their consistency. Internally, you can measure engagement and retention levels (across departments and geographies) and make adjustments to improve them. It also provides an opportunity for other departments to understand what works and what causes disenchantment or high retention rates.
Health and Productivity in an Organisation
Employee wellness programmes have expanded in importance as a result of remote work, COVID-19, and increased mental health awareness. Any organisation must determine whether their health and wellness programmes compare to others and have an influence on productivity.
What Are the Benefits of Benchmarking?
Increasing Business Influence
Setting benchmarks for HR leaders to tie employees' practices to company goals. For example, if your staff engagement score falls below the industry average, you should consider how this affects overall business performance. It guarantees that you make data-driven decisions rather than relying just on your gut or instincts.
Identifying Trends
Understanding your standards allows you to stay current with advances in your sector. It gives the information required to make decisions that will keep you competitive as an employer, as well as assistance in designing efficient HR programmes. For example, if benchmarks show that similar organisations with a wellness programme are more productive, it would be wise to implement a wellness programme.
Understand How a Company Stands up Opposed to Competition
Without the proper data to back up your view, it will be impossible to determine how your company compares to its counterparts, which could put your company in a bad situation. Understanding how your business compares to others in your industry is an example of external benchmarking. Once you understand your company's strengths and shortcomings in comparison to other brands in the sector, you may develop strategies to increase future performance levels.
Improve Current Practices
You may honestly evaluate your recruitment, retention, remuneration, talent, and development of leadership processes, identifying areas for improvement. Leaders and HR leaders are held accountable in this manner.
Effective Recruitment and Retention Programmes
A company's success is determined by the people it hires. Hiring the best personnel is a critical goal for any organisation that wants to succeed. Setting benchmarks in HR can help you attract high-quality prospects by defining what constitutes great potential hiring and the type of compensation that employees seek when applying for employment. It can also help an organisation to retain existing employees.
Assessing and Improving Employee Experience and Engagement
It also has an overall impact on your employer brand, as employees share the word about their employee experience. Improving your HR operations and becoming a best-in-class employer will help you improve the employee experience and engagement.
Improve the Workplace Culture
Workplace culture influences everything in the office, from employee performance to overall morale. As a business owner, you must strive for a better workplace culture and how employees perceive your brand. Your and your employees' goals should be aligned so that everyone is working together to grow the business. Employees who lack passion for their jobs may produce lower-quality work, which can be detrimental to your company.
Disadvantages of Benchmarking
Unhealing Market Comparing
One issue you may face is that it is not always easy to immediately compare your data with other organisations or even internally. As a result, you should use setting benchmarks in HR as one of several data points for optimising your procedures rather than the only signal.
Lack of Agreement on Taxonomy
Not every organisation uses the same name for all of its HR metrics or monitors them in the same way. Employee engagement and employee satisfaction are frequently used interchangeably, for example. Some organisations calculate the cost per hire from the day a post becomes vacant, while others calculate it from the date an employee resigns.
Conclusion
Setting benchmarks in HR necessitates both a reliable, up-to-date source of information and a willingness to act on the insights obtained through benchmarking. Gathering this data on your own is a demanding process, and without proper guidance on how to solve any issues that your organisation uncovers, all of your efforts may be in vain.
Benchmarks are usually used by organisations to make sure that their organisational actions, missions, and results are all there. Its specific area of interest relates to human resources in organisations, excluding personnel selection and placement, concentration whilst entrusting it with human resource practices within an organisation. By Looking at the core reasons for the variations in these instances, the HR team may also underline what particular practices and policies have been the most efficient while which need to be modified.
People also search for
FAQs
Why Do You Require Benchmarking?
An organisation may conduct a range of benchmarking studies to achieve several targets. Amongst the most critical ones is to boost the performance of the organisation. This leads the organisation to find efficiency comparison with its rivals. This will be done to point out the areas where the organisation does not do well so that they can think of ways to improve. When the weaknesses of the company have been determined, the organisation can now develop strategies to increase efficiency in those areas. It can play a vital role in these organisations and it can help them in outlining a framework of high achievement and learning from better competitors.
What Kinds of Companies Are the Beneficiaries to Benchmarks?
For many of the businesses there, it is also helpful. These organisations come to these boards to discuss quality improvement issues and how to measure success. The majority of them usually have a page for their action plan. They use it to keep the progress towards reaching their objectives on track. Moreover, those striving to enhance organisational processes may also use this tool. The purpose of setting benchmarks is twofold: it is an opportunity to measure and compare best practices and learn ways to optimise organisational procedures.
How Can Benchmarking Help in an Organisation?
It is a helpful method of evaluating organisational performance because it wants to compare many indicators, and features with internal or external benchmarks.
What Constitutes Effective Benchmarking?
To properly benchmark, and compare the same issue or procedure across organisations. This allows for the most objective and precise setting of benchmarks in HR is possible. To make a valid comparison, the comparison elements must be defined specifically and accurately.
How is internal benchmarking and external benchmarking different?
Benchmarking is not limited to comparing your organisation to others; it can also be done internally. Raising the bar for your best performers and improving all units internally enhances performance and is typically greeted with less pushback from managers. However, when comparing internal benchmarking, it may not provide answers to specific issues. Such as the reason behind employee retention rates are lower than that of a rival.
What is benchmarking in strategic management?
Strategic benchmarking is the process of comparing your strategy to those of other successful firms in order to uncover differences and opportunities. Understanding what high-performing firms do can help you optimise your business strategy and find opportunities for improvement.
Modify your HR and payroll tasks with factoHR today
Let your HR and workforce focus on most important business decisions while factoHR can reduce the burden of daily activities of the organization.
© 2024 Copyright factoHR